Who's going home tonight on American Idol 9 Top 6? Results Prediction + Poll

Who's going home tonight on the American Idol Top 6?

I'll just repeat my conspiracy theories from last night:

1. Aaron Kelly is the odds on favorite to leave. He sang at dreaded position #5 which is the kiss of death historically in the Top 6. Six out of the last 8 seasons, #5 has landed in the Bottom 3, and FOUR of those times, #5 was voted off. This included Carly Smithson (on a good night for her!) and Constantine Maroulis.

2. The other conspiracy is the American Idol 9 Compilation CD track list spoiler. That list correctly placed Tim Urban at #7 last week — and the person next on the list is Michael Lynche.

I think Aaron Kelly will be voted off tonight.

What do you guys think?

(Note: Join us for a chat later at 2 pm ET and listen to me on All Digital Radio at 12:15 pm ET for more Idol geekery.)