Randy Jackson and Simon Cowell - Catfight

So here it is: the Randy and Simon argument that firmly put American Idol on the map and made RJ Helton (and Jim Verraros and AJ Gil the 2 "losers") famous.

American Idol Season 1 included 2 gay contestants (maybe more!) who came out of the closet after the show, RJ being one of them. That's pretty awesome. The issue I think is whether the female American Idol viewer will reject a gay contestant. But women love gays, no? Or I'm just deluded? Or is it the parents who reject gays? Hmmm...

(Video clip after the jump)