Poll: Who's going home? American Idol 10 Top 4 Performance + Recap

I got a little confused tonight so we have two polls!

First, initially I thought the show was throwing Haley Reinhart under the bus after her first song. But after a great comeback performance with 'I Who Have Nothing' and a standing O from the judges, I realized that the show may be paving the way for a Lauren Alaina exit by making her fans complacent (and giving Haley tons of sympathy votes). I already see a surge in traffic for Haley tonight. So what happened? Are the judges really that inept they can't manipulate properly anymore? Or was it genius?

Who got thrown under the bus?

Who's going home? American Idol 10 Top 4 Performance

Join the Rickey.org American Idol Top 12 Office Pool.

Join the Rickey.org American Idol HitFix Fantasy League.

League Name: Rickey
Password: Rickey

Watch the video here: