Poll: American Idol Top 5 - Neil Diamond Week - Who Was Your Favorite?

Syesha Mercado was in her element this week giving us the best performance of the night even if Simon Cowell said she was in trouble. I've now penciled her in as high as Top 3.

The show was marred by Paula Abdul screwing the script and Neil Diamond songs.

David Cook, David Archuleta, Jason Castro, Brooke White