Who Made the Final Four on 'Survivor: Cagayan'?

The final four on Survivor: Cagayan have been chosen!

It was the result of a crazy episode in which Spencer won immunity (again) and caused Tony's alliance to begin cannibalizing itself sooner than planned. This led to a NUCLEAR blowup at camp between Trish and Kass that divided the lines between the two alliances, with Spencer and Kass on one side, Tony and Trish on the other, and Woo caught in the middle. Ultimately, this culminated in a tribal council that saw Woo finally (FINALLY) flip on Tony!

Credit: CBS

However, the flip in question didn't actually involve dumping Tony, but rather featured Woo deciding to team with Spencer and Kass to vote out Tony's #1 ally, Trish. This was a solid move since, from all accounts, Tony would still have a valuable ally to help get him to the end even if his idols no longer could be played. Of course, on the subject of idols, Tony made a blunder that could possibly cost him the game, as he decided to play his regular hidden immunity idol...for himself? This, despite having the protection of the special hidden immunity idol!

His rationale was that he needed to keep the special idol if his plan to convince his competitors it was still good at final four was ever going to work. But this seems even more boneheaded in retrospect, since Tony ended up not receiving any votes anyway! In essence, he could have played his regular idol for Trish and still kept his special idol. But that wasn't even the most perplexing move, as the final vote tally at the end of the show revealed that Tony actually voted for Trish. What the hell was his thought process there? I really hope this week's deleted scenes explain Tony's reasoning, because the edit clearly left out a vital piece of information (or Tony did. And really, either one is likely).

Of course, it's easy to play Monday Morning Quarterback with Survivor, but as we head into next week's finale, I feel as though Tony may have just made this game far harder for himself than it might need to be. So, without further adieu, the final four are...

Spencer Bledsoe, 21
Yung "Woo" Hwang, 29
Kassandra "Kass" McQuillen, 41
Tony Vlachos, 39

Let us know who you think will win, and who you think should win in the comments! And check out the recap and review of Episode 12 by clicking here!