Andrew Garcia - Sugar We're Going Down - Video MP3 American Idol Top 24 Performance

By Rickey ·

Andrew Garcia sings "Sugar We're Going Down" by Fall Out Boy on the American Idol Top 24

Download: Sugar We're Going Down

Ellen DeGeneres: I think the Paula song will carry you for a while. I think you're gonna stick around - we like you.

Kara DioGuardi: It was a strange rendition of that song.

Randy Jackson: The arrangement was really strange for me. This felt a little try hard.

Simon Cowell: I was disappointed with that. It was too indulgent. Really really fantastic recording voice.

I'm kinda shocked that Simon did not like this -- and then I lost my train of thought as to how I felt about it. It did seem indulgent but he's safe into the Top 12 and the tour, and clearly one the main stars this season.

Watch the video here:

Video no longer available.

American Idol