American Idol - Season 11 - Elimination Conspiracy

By Noelle Gruber ·

Put on your tin foil hats and have a seat because it's time for another American Idol Conspiracy! My favorite kind.

A crafty fan on Tumblr recently noticed that the collage on the American Idol Official Twitter was questionable. The order in which the contestants appear has, so far, been the exact same order the contestants have been eliminated. Last week when it was posted, Skylar was up next. Shockingly, the country girl was eliminated although being safe on Dialidol. (Not that that means anything.)

Is there something to this? If this collage continues it's curse, the next to go is Phillip with Mantasia Joshua winning the whole thing. I can definitely see this happening. Hollie is the Haley of this season.

Thanks to my fabulous friend Steph for the heads up.

Elimination order:

10. Erika

9. Heejun (:( I miss him already.)

8. Deandre

7. Colton

6. Elise

5. Skylar

~The Future

4. Phillip (noooo)

3. Jessica

2. Hollie

1. Joshua

Update: Nigel Lythgoe responds to our conspiracy theory:

American Idol