American Idol 9 Top 5 - Recap + Poll + Roundup

It's the songs of Frank Sinatra with Harry Connick, Jr. as mentor!

Aaron Kelly did a great job opening the show. Simon Cowell did not like the vocal too much but said that the audience likes Aaron because he looks like he tries his best.

Casey James gave a really uncomfortable performance tonight. He looked like he did not want to be there.

Crystal Bowersox looked stunning in her dress. Judges thought it was a bit subdued. Simon said she had two "OK" performances and needs to step it up next week if she wants to win.

Michael Lynche did well with a 'story' song which fits his 'emotive' style of singing. Not my thing, but a lot of people loved it.

Lee Dewyze was the best of the night. Best song choice and he really delivered. My dark horse pick is getting closer and closer to the prize.

Who was your favorite tonight?

Poll

Roundup

Old Blue Eyes Has Left the Building (Howard Stump)

Frank Sinatra Night: The summary (USA Today)

Casey's Baaaad Rendition of Sinatra Is Decidedly CapriCorny (Vote for the Worst)

‘American Idol’ Tears Up Ol’ Blue Eyes (Fancast)